Time 11:00 AM, Date 15/08/2018
  Change Font Size:     

Contradiction in the reply of PIO and FAA

Information regarding entry and departure timings of a particular vehicle as per the record book of a toll plaza was sought by the appellant. The respondent was absent at the hearing despite valid and timely notice of the CIC for which warning was issued to the concerned respondent PIO and Project Director, National Highways Authority of India. The CIC observed that the concerned PIO should desist from committing such lapse in future. The PIO claimed that relevant records are not available whereas the First Appellate Authority claimed that the sought for information is a third party information, hence, the same cannot be provided u/s 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act. The PIO and Project Director, NHAI was directed to state on affidavit to the CIC that the information provided on these points is factually correct, based on records and nothing is hidden therein.


The PIO should either take a prior permission of the CIC before abstaining himself from the hearing or he should send a proper representative to attend the hearing before the CIC after obtaining due permission from the CIC for doing so and after ensuring that the authorised representative is briefed appropriately.

Citation: Dilip Joshi v. National Highways Authority of India in File No.: CIC/ NHAIN /A/2017/102258, Date of hearing: 20.03.2018, 13.07.2018

Dr. Anuradha Verma (dranuradhaverma@yahoo.co.in) is the co-author of the books: RIGHT TO INFORMATION – LAW AND PRACTICE and PIO’s guide to RTI. Her other articles can be read at the website of RTI Foundation of India at http://www.rtifoundationofindia.com/
  Todays Whispers

¤  This is History (892)

¤  Peace cannot be kept by force; it can only be achieved by understanding.

¤  What is similarity between Modi and Shivraj Singh ?

¤  Was Sandhu repatriated on Karnataka govt's request ?

¤  B S Bishnoi completes his tenure as Ambassador to Thailand

¤  HDFC Bank most likely to choose CEO from within

¤  No suitable candidate found for Director (Fin), RCIL

¤  942 Personnel awarded Police Medals

¤  CBI officers awarded President’s and Police Medals

¤  President’s police medal for distinguished service:

¤  Police medal for meritorious service:

¤  SFIO arrests a Promoter of Bhushan Steel Limited

¤  Two Assistant Archaeologists shifted

¤  Dr Srinivas Rao appointed Economic Adviser, Pharmaceuticals

¤  Justice M.S. Ramesh angry over judges’ seat behind ministers

¤  Last date for Development Commissioner, SEZ, Kolkata extended

¤  ACIDS (PP&FS), HQ, IDS is Member of MoD’s CPRC

¤  M R Deora posted to South Eastern Railway

¤  D K Mondal given addl. charge as CHOD, CLW

¤  Neeraj Agarwal posted to Northern Railway

Read All Whispers...

– What will be the political scenario in the country after 2
Copyight @2009 whispersinthecoridors.in VIEWERS Free Web Site Counter