Time 11:00 AM, Date 17/01/2019
  Change Font Size:     

RTI
Separate reply for separate RTI applications

Appellant submitted before the CIC that he has not received any reply from the CPIO or the FAA till date regarding his query about the ownership of a particular land. In response to a show cause notice for imposition of penalty, the PIO regretted that the RTI Application dated 31.03.2017 was not replied to. He further submitted that later, Appellant filed a RTI another RTI Application dated 02.02.2018 wherein he sought information which is covered in the information sought in RTI Application dated 31.03.2017 also. A reply dated 28.02.2018 was sent to the Appellant asking him to inspect documents and take copies as required. The PIO prayed that the show-cause proceedings may be dropped as there was no malafide intention in the failure to provide a reply on the RTI Application dated 31.03.2017 within the stipulated time frame. The CIC observed that the facts of the case reflect very poorly on the lack of rationality of the PIO even as malafide intention is not evinced. The CIC dropped the show-cause proceedings with a severe warning to the PIO to remain careful in future.

Comments

All the PIO’s should remember that each RTI Application has to be dealt as per the provisions of RTI Act. Merely on a belief that two very distinct RTI Applications seek similar information,a PIO cannot absolve himself from the statutory duty of replying to one of the RTI Applications within the stipulated time frame of RTI Act. Reply to one RTI Application cannot take care of the other even if the information is similar.application.

Citation:Kartik B Joshi v. CPIO O/o Cantonment Board, Devlali Cantt in Adjunct Decision File No. : CIC/IARMY/A/2017/155555/SD/Adjunct, Date : 26/12/2018
  Todays Whispers

¤  This is History (924)



¤  Who blocked re-union of Gandhi family ?



¤  Why did Rahul go to Dubai ?



¤  Cabinet Secretary’s two year term fixed during Atal’s tenure



¤  This time PM is very cautious !



¤  Selection Panel to choose new CBI Director on Jan 24



¤  Sanjiv Arora to succeed Muley as Secretary in MEA



¤  Tenure of Suresh Arora as DGP, Punjab extended



¤  Three posts of GM vacant in Railways



¤  Two new Supreme Court Judges



¤  Naik is new SP NIA



¤  Consent of all three Chiefs of defence forces required for restructuring proposals



¤  Two Members posts vacant in NHRC



¤  Interviews for CMD of Powergrid postponed



¤  Subhash Chandra Gupta joins as Director (W&W), KRCL



¤  Tenure of Bhaskar as CMD, BDL ends in Feb; Mishra likely to succeed him



¤  Gajendra Singh is also Chairman IGL



¤  Bhopal Literature and Art Festival - Part 1



¤  Javed Akhtar appointed Addl CIT, CBDT



¤  Shemsingh Alexander Bathew appointed DG, Audit, Eastern Railway



¤  Vivek Srivastava empanelled as ADG in GoI



¤  Ms Dubey transferred to Tourism Ministry



¤  Aman Sharma Joins as Director without relieving order ?



¤  ISS officers were not considered for CSS ?



¤  Mishra is also Pr. Resident Commissioner, Rajasthan Govt at New Delhi



¤  Two CSS officers posted as Deputy Secretaries in GoI



¤  Justice P K Jaiswal appointed as Judge, Allahabad High Court (UPDATED)



¤  Justice Ramendra continues as Additional Judge, Punjab & Haryana HC (UPDATED)



¤  N S Murali appointed as IG Forests in NTCA (UPDATED)



¤  Chandra Prakash Khanduja appointed as Regional Director, Forest Survey of India (UPDATED)



¤  Prime Minister visits power pavilion at Vibrant Gujarat Summit (UPDATED)



Read All Whispers...



 
DEBATE
– What will be the political scenario in the country after 2
Copyight @2009 whispersinthecoridors.in VIEWERS Free Web Site Counter