Monday, November 16, 2026
Live
“
“
Voices from the corridors

Whispers Forum

Debates, reader views and sharp takes on the issues shaping governance — a new conversation every week, archived by date.

0 posts 0 months Latest: 24 Jan 2023
  Browse by date   All posts3234
  2026237
  2025357
  2024357
  2023357
  2022351
  2021342
  2020349
  2019340
  2018332
  2017212

Forum & RTI 3,234 posts · page 108 of 270

Tuesday, 24 January 2023
Forum

Air India staff still having hangover of GoI

Recently, I traveled by Air India from Del to Bangalore and back, the staff of Air India is still having hangover of Govt of India employ as long as they continue to work as per their previous practice nothing important change will be visible on the ground and travelers will suffer which will ultimately affect the Band Tata.
Umesh Nawani
Monday, 23 January 2023
Forum

RTI information must be shared

I agree with Sudhanshu Trivedi ji RTI information must be shared fully. Not sharing information means defeat of the purpose of RTI Act. As of date it seems RTI is dead now as information is never shared with the excuse of National interest or security of nation or State as the case may be. Government must find a solution to this issue
Harish Kumar
RTI

Proper application fee

The Respondent submitted that the instant RTI Application seeking information about the EPF has not been registered for want of appropriate Indian Postal Order (IPO). As the postal order was not drawn on the local postal office, it could not be encashed and hence, the PIO returned the application for the want of requisite fee. The initial IPO was returned and the Appellant was informed regarding the correct mode of payment but the Appellant did not adhere to the same. The CIC observed that the instant RTI Application has not been registered till date for want of mandatory fee through the appropriate mode of payment. Hence, the CIC considered the Second Appeal as ‘infructuous’.
Comments
The IPO should be drawn in the favour of the Accounts Officer of the public authority. If the name of the Office is not known, the name of the city may be mentioned on the IPO while stating the number of the IPO on the RTI application.
Citation: Rukmani Panigrahi v. Food Corporation of India in Second Appeal No. CIC/FCIND/A/2021/153974, Date: 20.01.2023
Dr Anuradha Verma (dranuradhaverma@yahoo.co.in) is a RTI Consultant currently working with IIM Visakhapatnam. She has co-authored the books, RTI Right to Information - Law and Practice and PIO’s Guide to RTI. She offers consultancy on RTI matters and Third party audit. Her other articles can be read at the website of RTI Foundation of India at the link www.rtifoundationofindia.com
Saturday, 21 January 2023
Forum

CCI needs tough guys

The CCI needs tough guys who break the present ways and punish the violators. Like me for example. I will teach these bureaucrats a few lessons.
Ashok Menon
Friday, 20 January 2023
Forum

Public interest to disclose or deny information

In many cases it is known that someone has committed a wrong and needs a document to prove it. It is felt that in cases of serious allegations, the documents should be provided under RTI as there would be no way to otherwise prove an allegation. A culprit may use the privacy provision to prevent any information from going out and the system would act to prevent any leakage of information. Such a closed system breeds corruption and nepotism. It would be in the public interest to disclose the information under RTI Act to deny or prove the charges.
Sudhanshu Trivedi
Thursday, 19 January 2023
Forum

DG sir, please feel our pain

Honourable Director General of Police. Sir, my name is Moi Bomjen, son of late Yamo Bomjen. My father was in your police department as constable. He died on December 6, 2006. Sir, it's been 16 years. Please consider us as your daughter, son and family members. Please feel our pain. I heartily request you with our fold hands. We are victims of compassionate ground. Name Moi Bomjen Mobile No. 8731002354
Moi Bomjen
Wednesday, 18 January 2023
Forum

Indian bureaucracy is accountable for all decisions

Indian bureaucracy needs to be accountable as their decisions and actions directly impact economic growth, national security and social well being of the country.
Naresh Kumar
Tuesday, 17 January 2023
Forum

Agree with views expressed by Col V K Gupta

I fully agree with views expressed by Col. V K Gupta regarding MoD and mismanagement, especially service officers. I know one case one officer was boarded out of services due to medical reasons, medical condition happened due to duty activities, was boarded out in 1979 but got his pension, pension arrears in end 2005, even after SC judgment payment was delayed for two years, all this happened courtesy mismanagement or mishandling by MoD stalwarts. GoI must pull them or give some powers to services itself.
Harish Kumar
Monday, 16 January 2023
Forum

Pak was a major producer of wheat

Pakistan was a major producer of wheat. It had got better irrigation system in 1947. Now it imports wheat. But the Ukraine and Russian war has prevented them from accessing those countries. They can buy from wheat but they will have to bend their ego to something which they will not.
A K Agnihotri
Trials should be on fast track
Totally agree with the implied suggestion of selected cases of harassment. These are total wastage and diversion of time, focus and efforts on wasteful exercise instead for devotion to duty. These trials should be fast tracked and not linger on endlessly causing financial, time & emotional drain of a soldier
Himanshu
RTI

Allegation of altering date of birth for recruitment

The appellant submitted before the CIC that the denial of information u/s 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act is not correct as the third party against whom he had sought information had submitted fake documents, altering his date of birth to get recruited into the Army. He argued that the matter is of public interest and the information should be provided to him. The PIO informed that there is no documentary evidence regarding manipulation of date of birth in civil education certificate in respect of said individuals. The CIC observed that all the notings/ correspondence which took place while processing of the said complaint becomes personal information of that third party and except for the final outcome of the complaint, no other information can be provided to the appellant. Therefore, the CPIO was right in denying the information u/s 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act. The CIC noted that the appellant had already filed an FIR which will take separate cognizance of the accusation if the accused is found guilty.
Comments
This case shows that mere allegation is not enough to invoked the clause of public interest. It has to be backed by evidence if the desires that the personal information be disclosed. Similarly, it has the contention in many cases that the file-notings should be disclosed if the person has been found guilty or otherwise.
Dr Anuradha Verma (dranuradhaverma@yahoo.co.in) is a RTI Consultant currently working with IIM Visakhapatnam. She has co-authored the books, RTI Right to Information - Law and Practice and PIO’s Guide to RTI. She offers consultancy on RTI matters and Third party audit. Her other articles can be read at the website of RTI Foundation of India at the link www.rtifoundationofindia.com
Saturday, 14 January 2023
Forum

Opposition needs a master speaker

I think the opposition needs a master speaker. What he says need not be correct or true, but must sound convincing to Indian crowds.
B K Saha
Joshimath— a man-made tragedy
A K Saxena is right in saying that the Joshimath tragedy is man made and not a natural disaster. What to talk of Joshimath where serious cracks in hundreds of houses and on roads have developed actually many parts of this beautiful state have been ruined by constructing hydro power projects on the rivers or by cutting trees. Forest fires have been very common during this season. After retirement, my husband and I have been going regularly to the state in winter mostly this very month and we found on our way some place or the forest on fire. It was either due to carelessness when cigarette butts are thrown on the dry pine grass called parli in local language which is highly inflammable .The dry pine grass falls during these months and catches fire and spreads fast and burns the trees. Sometimes deliberately the fire is lit to clear the space for some construction by some antisocial elements. Widening of roads by blasting the hillside has been the cause of many landslides. Of course Chardham Pari yojna for which environment clearance has been obtained for defence needs so that our troops can reach the border quickly has definitely not been in the interest of safeguarding ecology. The NTPC Tapovan hydro power project, it seems, has also impacted the fragile land with its digging of tunnels. To save the incidents like in Joshimath we have to deal very delicately with any development model adopted for the state.
Aarti Khosla
Friday, 13 January 2023
Forum

Court cases by Soldiers against MoD / GoI

Soldiers defend the country from external aggression, manage disaster, and are the backbone of our country. It has been seen that civilians in MOD deliberately create circumstances wherein they have to get redress from honorable courts including Supreme Court of India. Many times cases are won by the soldiers. Shouldn't the erring babus be punished sternly for causing financial loss to the exchequer as well as the soldiers. Since the cases are decided after a prolonged duration there's financial loss to the exchequer as well as soldiers. Could there be a nexus between babus in siphoning off so much money from govt coffers. I feel it's high time to put an end to such a menace and give soldiers their due without harassment.
Col V K Gupta