Technical entry scheme of Indian Army
Media reports have come stating that only those who have secured a good rank in IIT-JEE Main examination will be an essential requirement for selection to the technical branches of Indian Army through Technical entry scheme. It is very short sighted and unfair policy.
First of all, those who secure a good rank in IIT-JEE, and more so their parents, think that such children are gift of God to humankind but not to the Armed Forces. Given a choice, how many parents of such children will let their children prefer the armed forces over IITs.
Getting into an IIT is the first step towards realising the American dream for such children. Or they will go for the IIT/IIM combo after which they will enter careers selling cigarettes, alcohol, potato wafers etc or inti investment banking, management consulting all of which offer a starting salary which is more than what the Chief of Army gets after 40 years of service. Surely the choice is clear.
Another important aspect is that almost all the children who get good ranks in IIT-JEE are likely to be middle to upper income families from metros with access and affordability to very expensive coaching schools. All this will deprive boys from tier-2/3 towns and rural areas ,who are otherwise quite intelligent, deprive them forever from joining the armed forces.
This is grossly unfair. The Armed Forces must realise and reconcile to the fact taht the catchment area for manpower for them will be only from rural areas and smaller towns. Armed Forces must also realise that they too have an obligation to contribute to the economic well being of citizens in rural areas.
What requires upgradation is not the standard of students which is quite adequate but the standard of their technical training establishments, their faculty, infrastructure, testing methods etc. Instead of going for a soft and lazy option of insisting on IIT-JEE ranks, they should bring up the standards of their training school to the level of IITs. They actively seek the help of IITs for this purpose. IITs are also funded by the government and they should come forward to help th Armed Forces upgrade their institutions. I do hope many ex-servicemen among the readers of this site will take this up and see that justice is done to large number of rural children including children of exservicemen.
R. Subramanian
First of all, those who secure a good rank in IIT-JEE, and more so their parents, think that such children are gift of God to humankind but not to the Armed Forces. Given a choice, how many parents of such children will let their children prefer the armed forces over IITs.
Getting into an IIT is the first step towards realising the American dream for such children. Or they will go for the IIT/IIM combo after which they will enter careers selling cigarettes, alcohol, potato wafers etc or inti investment banking, management consulting all of which offer a starting salary which is more than what the Chief of Army gets after 40 years of service. Surely the choice is clear.
Another important aspect is that almost all the children who get good ranks in IIT-JEE are likely to be middle to upper income families from metros with access and affordability to very expensive coaching schools. All this will deprive boys from tier-2/3 towns and rural areas ,who are otherwise quite intelligent, deprive them forever from joining the armed forces.
This is grossly unfair. The Armed Forces must realise and reconcile to the fact taht the catchment area for manpower for them will be only from rural areas and smaller towns. Armed Forces must also realise that they too have an obligation to contribute to the economic well being of citizens in rural areas.
What requires upgradation is not the standard of students which is quite adequate but the standard of their technical training establishments, their faculty, infrastructure, testing methods etc. Instead of going for a soft and lazy option of insisting on IIT-JEE ranks, they should bring up the standards of their training school to the level of IITs. They actively seek the help of IITs for this purpose. IITs are also funded by the government and they should come forward to help th Armed Forces upgrade their institutions. I do hope many ex-servicemen among the readers of this site will take this up and see that justice is done to large number of rural children including children of exservicemen.
R. Subramanian