Monday, November 16, 2026
Live
“
“
Voices from the corridors

Whispers Forum

Debates, reader views and sharp takes on the issues shaping governance — a new conversation every week, archived by date.

0 posts 0 months Latest: 18 Feb 2021
  Browse by date   All posts3234
  2026237
  2025357
  2024357
  2023357
  2022351
  2021342
  2020349
  2019340
  2018332
  2017212

Forum & RTI 3,234 posts · page 164 of 270

Thursday, 18 February 2021
Forum

Whispers Forum — 18 Feb 2021

DEBATE(1)
Infact word of committed bureaucracy started from the days of Indira Gandhi and now the same tradition is there. Officers may not like to be called “Babu”.
T C Sharma
Yes it's correct to use Word Babu
As most of the policies and instructions passed is on papers and after certain number of service they became file pushers.
Avi Liesha
GM posts in Railways not deputation posts
GM posts in Indian Railways are not deputation posts ! However there is no bar on Railway officers to apply for deputations advertised by other organisations!
Neeraj Dinkar
Wednesday, 17 February 2021
Forum

Whispers Forum — 17 Feb 2021

DEBATE(1)
The word “Babu” is a derogatory, colonial slang with pejorative connotation. Its abuse by present day politicians and the media, is disdainful. Ironically, Sardar Patel called civil servants, the steel frame of India.
In his Parliament speech on Feb 10,2021, PM Modi came down heavily on India’s ‘babu culture’. His “Sab kuch babu hi karenge” jibe is insulting, smacking of arrogance and authoritarianism.
Neither the serving, nor the re-appointed civil servants could question Head of Government. Spineless, compromised “ babus”
But, who made the civil servants ‘babus’ in the first place ? Guess, who benefits the most from the so-called ‘babudom’ ? It is the political class. And, PM knows it well.
A K Saxena (A former civil servant)
Injustice meted out to Promotee ACs of 2014 Batch
I have been regularly following the issue of Promotee ACs of 2014 Batch, belonging to CBIC. Grave injustice is being done to them as their Direct Recruited counterparts Batch till 2016 have already been promoted. CBIC needs their valuable services, yet disown them. Is it their fault that they were promoted against temporary vacancies? Even Supreme Court in many of its judgments has stated that any temporary vacancy being continued for more than an year can't be treated as temporary and any AC who has completed 4 years of residency period in JTS, should be upgraded to STS, irrespective of temporary, ad hoc or regular. CBIC has already issued an order no. 07/2021 dt: 14/01/2021, in which even Commissioners promoted in 2012 have been shown as ad hoc promotees. CBIC has deliberately not included these vacancies in Recruitment Rules of Gr. A Services due to its partisan attitude towards Promotee ACs, who have been rightly termed as beast of burden by Gopal Reddy. The Directorate of HRD is defunct in CBIC and needs to be re-organised. The Chairman is well aware of this issue, but not at all interested in sorting out this issue. Will Revenue Secretary, FM and PMO intervene in the matter to grant NFU in the grade of STS as DCs ? The Promotee ACs of 2014 assure the PM that they will walk extra mile to increase revenue realisation for nation building.
Neeraj Kumar Dutt
Tuesday, 16 February 2021
Forum

Whispers Forum — 16 Feb 2021

DEBATE (1)
Babus will be Babus, the remnant of Colonial era, till the time they become public servants in the true sense instead of working as servants of the ruling dispensation.
Paarth Garg
DEBATE (2)
PM's statement on Babudom has a loud message : The motion of thanks to the President's address in the Rajya Sabha has a clear message to Babus. Power galleries are also interpreting the PM's speech in their own way. But one thing is for sure that the govt is not going to tolerate those babus who are non- performers.
A Chaturvedi
CBDT has many challenges
Chairman, CBDT has made significant contribution in the budget 2021-22 proposal now it is the time for its implementation. Pre-filled ITR forms with addition of dividend income and LTCG will also be available. It is forward step towards success and making tax compliance tax payers friendly. Apart from this most important is to make ITR filing truly online from e-filing website i.e. making filing without generating XML and uploading. It will be really ease the problem of ITR filing without any compatibility issue of software. It will lead to easy, seamless and painless ITR filing. Tax compliance will be higher and increase tax revenue. We have best software experts and no problem making ITR filing truly on line from e-filing website. CBDT has to reorient the officers and making them available for this innovative work instead of doing non-productive work. CBDT should close all old cases older than 3 years where no tax liability has been fixed and are not in any dispute. Such message or directives should go to field units. Such cases where only letters have been issued for trifle matters. This can be started with Sr. Citizens specially house-wives. It will save man power and time. This will avoid VIVAD. Another important thing how to reduces excess cash transactions in any agreement and make truly digital. Let us hope for moving towards easy, seamless and painless tax compliance system in addition to faceless.
Naveen
Monday, 15 February 2021
Forum

Rly officer goes on deputation to Meghalaya Government

What is the bright idea? How would the Railway officers react if an IFS officer was appointed GM of a Zone?
Amitabh Agarwal
Saturday, 13 February 2021
Forum

Reader views on DATE with RTI — 13 Feb 2021

This is an interesting case which should be keenly watched by all those with a commercial interest. It is not disputed that the applicant was a legal heir. He may not be the sole heir but that does not deprive him of the right to seek information about the complete property of which he has inherited a part. For instance, can it be said that since he inherited on third of the property, he is entitled to know only one third part of the Income tax return? One should be allowed access to complete information and denial of information is unjustified in such a case. The information commission has time and again showed lack of comprehension of legal concepts and this is a case which exemplifies the bureaucratic mindset from where the Information Commissioners come from.
Hemant Kukunoor
Friday, 12 February 2021
Forum

“Second round of lateral entry by UPSC”

At the behest of GoI, UPSC has announced the second round of lateral recruitment of officers at the levels of Joint Secretary and Director on contract basis, in several central ministries.
There is a condition imposed by the government : Only, the "talented and motivated Indian nationals willing to contribute towards nation-building", need apply.
An affront to the corrupt, laidback Indian bureaucracy. Is it not talented and motivated enough?
The ministries / departments are :-- Commerce & Industry, Department of Financial Services, Department of Economic Affairs, Agriculture & Farmers Welfare, Law & Justice, Department of School Education & Literacy, Department of Higher Education, Consumer Affairs, Food & Public Distribution, Health & Family Welfare, Road Transport & Highways, Jal Shakti, Civil Aviation, Skill Development and Entrepreneurship.
Privatisation of bureaucracy. We are stealthily moving towards the american system of Committed bureaucracy. The selection will naturally be based on the doctrine of “ pick and choose” emanating from discretionary powers.
Stamp of approval by UPSC, is a mere formality to give the selection a sense of legitimacy.
It may be recalled that a couple of laterally-inducted bureaucrats in the first round, had to resign.
Did they fail to adjust to new environment, its ethical approach and fear of anti-corruption agencies, one wonders?
Is the new system flawed ? Has any impact assessment study carried out by the GoI on the performance of recruits of first round? If not, why?
Against this backdrop ,the government’s talk of " Minimum Government ,Maximum Governance”, is farce. Reverse is happening, instead.
Massive pressure from private sector especially friendly business magnates, is suspected .
A K Saxena (A former civil servant)
Thursday, 11 February 2021
Forum

Is this democracy ?

Those who say farmers do not understand the benefits of Farm Laws show their own ignorance. They think farmers are illiterate and 'ganwar'. The fact of the matter is they not only understand the impact of these laws too well on their future but also follow the policies and intentions of the establishment in large scale disinvestment being planned which is going to result in further unemployment. The children of farmers are educated and know the implications of these laws which were pushed through the parliament without debate because of brutal majority in Lok Sabha and louder voice in Rajya Sabha. The Farmers have been maligned, humiliated and tortured enough what with barbed wires, ditches and spikes. It is happening in the country we proudly claim to be democracy. If this is democracy where voice of people is not heard and journalists are put in jail for reporting facts or FIRs are slapped on them for tweeting what is denied by police we have to find another definition for this.
Aarti Khosla
Wednesday, 10 February 2021
Forum

Focus on Good Governance to ensure better results from Budget

It is interesting to read A. K. Saxena's article on farmers/budget under Forum. It appears to present one side of the story. The fact remains that the farmer leaders have failed to convince the nation about the problem with the present laws under dispute. Instead of ignoring the farmers, the present government's has fully ignored the middle class including the government servants, working as well as retired. Moreover, managing the expenditure through the sale of assets is not a sign of good financial management. However, the basic issue in the governance remains the simplification of procedures and fixing of the responsibility. The present government has failed on both the counts. The patch-work done by the present government in this direction has not achieved the desired goals. It has just ensured successful completion of certain projects. In fact, shifting of the focus from the overall responsibility to the completion of certain projects has been counter productive for good governance. The problem of common man remains getting rough treatment from the various establishments.
A. K. Verma, ISS (Retd.)
Tuesday, 9 February 2021
Forum

CP Delhi should take action

I agree with Aarti Khosla's observations. Most of the times Police are responsible for traffic jams as they put barricades (unmanned) and leave it for days!! This is despite CP, Delhi's order on this issue. Hope CP Delhi would take note of it and take action.
Subramanian Gopal
Monday, 8 February 2021
RTI

ITR details of deceased father

The appellant sought the ITR details of his father Late Sh. Madan Lal. He admitted that he is not the sole heir of Late Sh. Madan Lal. The respondent contended that there is an ongoing dispute among the brothers of the appellant with regard to the sole heirship and accordingly, they have claimed exemption under Section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act for denying the ITR details. The CIC held that in the absence of any larger public interest in the matter, the appellant is not entitled to seek the ITR details of Late Sh. Madan Lal which is exempted under Section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act, 2005.
Comments
Ordinarily, the legal heir is entitled to the information pertaining to the deceased. This case throws up a situation where there are multiple legal heirs and only one is seeking the information.
Citation: Kamal Aggarwal v. O/o the Income Tax Officer in Second Appeal Nos. CIC/CCITC/A/2018/155973 CIC/CCITC/A/2018/155918, CIC/CCITC/A/2018/155917, CIC/CCITC/A/2018/155916 & CIC/CCITC/A/2018/155914, Date of Decision: 22-01-2021
Dr. Anuradha Verma (dranuradhaverma@yahoo.co.in) is an expert on RTI matters and has co-authored the books RIGHT TO INFORMATION - LAW AND PRACTICE and PIO’s guide to RTI. Apart from her weekly article here, her other articles can be read at the website of RTI Foundation of India at the link: www.rtifoundationofindia.com
Forum

Fallacious budget projection

I fully support the views expressed by AK Saxena regarding pro corporate and anti kissan budget 2021-22. I am shocked media, GoI. RBI and many are projecting 10.5% growth from -23.5%, effectively 33.5%. Is it feasible especially when defence figures are missing in the budget. Where is the roadmap for this enormous growth especially when consumer or voter has no money to purchase due to Covid-19 and also faulty economic policies since 2014, demonetization.
Harish Kumar
Pitching hard to remain in job after retirement
It seems that senior most bureaucrats of CBDT, Finance Ministry, DoR are pitching / trying to get their tenures extended after retirement.
Vinod
Saturday, 6 February 2021
Forum

“Corporate friendly, anti-Kisan, anti-poor budget will escalate Kisan agitation” !

The populist budget fy 21-22 , replete with confusing statistics, new economic jargons, new schemes with chaste Hindi nomenclatures to dupe farmers and the common man. Anti-kisan and anti- poor budget could escalate the kisan agitation irretrievably.
Budget is PM-centric ( not poor-centric) to get cheap publicity for the coming Assemblies' elections. Manipulating data, as always. Budget is high on promises and low on benefits to the poor. How many promises were executed successfully in the past?. Policy and implementation paralyses, would confront us as we go along.
Mobilising resources through gimmick like "Assets Monetization", is dangerous. It would lead to selling Railway, Defence, PSUs land assets, offloading PSU’s stakes to corporate houses, handing over construction and maintenance of Airports, Railways to the two top Gujarati businesses honchos. Guess, who ? They will construct ware houses, cold storages, fleece farmers and increase their illegal wealth.
Misplaced priorities. All dirty tricks are being applied to deflect public attention from core issues. Such unethical practices were common during the Congress- led UPA rule. Nothing unusual.
PM’s appeal to agitating farmers to contact him being only a " phone call away " amounts to mockery of farmers . Mere political rhetoric.
Is PM not aware that farmers at Delhi’s three borders are under siege of Delhi police surrounded by the 12-layered barricades, barbed wire fencing, concrete walls with iron nails to prevent the ingress and egress of protesting farmers and public. Aaisy gherabandi Lal Quila par kyon nahi banai ? Government in catch-22 situation !
Most baffling ? Where is the mysterious guy called Deep Sidhu who allegedly led the mob to Red fort to unfurl the religious flag at the pole ? His photograph in the privileged company of PM and HM has gone viral. Was he planted by the ruling party with specific mission to derail the otherwise peaceful march.? Where is he hiding ? Why has Delhi police not booked him for sedition ?
The ostrich-like attitude of paid media particularly since persons affected belong to the most vulnerable sections of society, reveals their motive is suspect.
No doubt, the public is being inconvenienced due to heavy police barricading. But, who is to blame ? Royal obstinacy of decision makers, directly or indirectly abetted by the ineffective, incompetent and irresponsible political Opposition led by the Congis , Commies and their moronic allies plus, plus, plus ! The nincompoops have neither the spine, the calibre nor the face to oppose.
The adverse impact of budget will be felt, years later by the posterity ,who will never forgive the government for wonky priorities for petty political gains.
A K Saxena (A former civil servant