When will arm chair reformists have courage to speak truth ?
Some person has, the other day, written about bureaucratic reforms in Indian Express. When will these arm chair reformists have courage to speak the truth ?
1. Can you have a bureaucrat deliver when the Minister is corrupt/a criminal/a mafia don/a real estate dealer ? Will that minister ever like to have ANY good bureaucrat in his department?
2. Once, after the CM was impressed with my performance as Secretary, i told the CM that the DM of his district (his favourite ) was very corrupt and he should remove him immediately, he kept quiet. The DM continued for years. There are hundred such stories.
3. The ministers are chosen from amongst MPs/MLAs by the PM/CM as ministers. For the first time this PM has chosen domain experts like R K Singh and S Jaishankar. Unless electoral reforms are done ensuring that ONLY honest citizens who are dedicated to the nation (like Sri Modi himself) can win elections, bureaucracy will function at sub-optimal level.
4. If you don't have good ministers, frequent transfers will ensure that the officer would not get enough time to deliver to the people. I myself have had tenures of 7 days, 3, 4, 6( as District Magistrate ), 9, 10( as District Magistrate ) months. My charge as JS in one ministry was changed twice in a 9 month tenure in GoI. Isn't it height of misgovernance ?
5. Then there are false criminal cases filed against a bureaucrat, he faces false defamation cases, assaults, murder etc etc etc all because he/she tries to follow the Rule of Law.
6. You would have often heard " there is so much corruption in DDA/CPWD/ Registration offices etc , wonder why the IAS officers heading them don't take action?". Let me explain. The moment you think of taking action, the politicos create all kinds of hurdles. If you are stubborn, you proceed and issue the charge sheet. The employee immediately goes to CAT/HC/SC. And once lawyers get on with their job it could be years before any action can be taken. You would have left that post (or transferred out by minister for taking action against this crony ) or retired by then. Every government servant knows that ultimately no harm will come to him. He would get back his post, promotions, arrears of pay ( with luck also interest on delayed payments ). In fact, in my personal experience, I even got slapped with ridiculously false criminal/civil cases right from the days as SDM and upto the day i retired as Secretary in GoI. The money spent, the harassment and time wasted by me anyone can guess. So unless delivery of court orders are quick, you cannot discipline a rogue employee. Judicial reforms is thus the other urgent need of the hour.
8. Unless you have good ministers and quick disposal of DE proceedings in court, there is very little you can do to improve governance. Time and again it has been seen that once political leadership is good there is no issue with the bureaucracy. Look at the present PM and his bureaucracy. He never complains about his bureaucrats and gets numerous of his policy decisions very effectively implemented by this very bureaucracy. The steed is high breed. What the poor fellow needs is a good rider.
Jai Hind !
Vande Mataram
P K Basu IAS (Retd)
Former Secretary GoI
Former Member, CAT
Report judgements of common interests
It would be worthwhile to report C A T judgements and S C judgements of common interests to a large no. of officers.
S K Sharma
1. Can you have a bureaucrat deliver when the Minister is corrupt/a criminal/a mafia don/a real estate dealer ? Will that minister ever like to have ANY good bureaucrat in his department?
2. Once, after the CM was impressed with my performance as Secretary, i told the CM that the DM of his district (his favourite ) was very corrupt and he should remove him immediately, he kept quiet. The DM continued for years. There are hundred such stories.
3. The ministers are chosen from amongst MPs/MLAs by the PM/CM as ministers. For the first time this PM has chosen domain experts like R K Singh and S Jaishankar. Unless electoral reforms are done ensuring that ONLY honest citizens who are dedicated to the nation (like Sri Modi himself) can win elections, bureaucracy will function at sub-optimal level.
4. If you don't have good ministers, frequent transfers will ensure that the officer would not get enough time to deliver to the people. I myself have had tenures of 7 days, 3, 4, 6( as District Magistrate ), 9, 10( as District Magistrate ) months. My charge as JS in one ministry was changed twice in a 9 month tenure in GoI. Isn't it height of misgovernance ?
5. Then there are false criminal cases filed against a bureaucrat, he faces false defamation cases, assaults, murder etc etc etc all because he/she tries to follow the Rule of Law.
6. You would have often heard " there is so much corruption in DDA/CPWD/ Registration offices etc , wonder why the IAS officers heading them don't take action?". Let me explain. The moment you think of taking action, the politicos create all kinds of hurdles. If you are stubborn, you proceed and issue the charge sheet. The employee immediately goes to CAT/HC/SC. And once lawyers get on with their job it could be years before any action can be taken. You would have left that post (or transferred out by minister for taking action against this crony ) or retired by then. Every government servant knows that ultimately no harm will come to him. He would get back his post, promotions, arrears of pay ( with luck also interest on delayed payments ). In fact, in my personal experience, I even got slapped with ridiculously false criminal/civil cases right from the days as SDM and upto the day i retired as Secretary in GoI. The money spent, the harassment and time wasted by me anyone can guess. So unless delivery of court orders are quick, you cannot discipline a rogue employee. Judicial reforms is thus the other urgent need of the hour.
8. Unless you have good ministers and quick disposal of DE proceedings in court, there is very little you can do to improve governance. Time and again it has been seen that once political leadership is good there is no issue with the bureaucracy. Look at the present PM and his bureaucracy. He never complains about his bureaucrats and gets numerous of his policy decisions very effectively implemented by this very bureaucracy. The steed is high breed. What the poor fellow needs is a good rider.
Jai Hind !
Vande Mataram
P K Basu IAS (Retd)
Former Secretary GoI
Former Member, CAT
Report judgements of common interests
It would be worthwhile to report C A T judgements and S C judgements of common interests to a large no. of officers.
S K Sharma