Monday, November 16, 2026
Live
“
“
Voices from the corridors

Whispers Forum

Debates, reader views and sharp takes on the issues shaping governance — a new conversation every week, archived by date.

0 posts 0 months Latest: 1 Jan 2019
  Browse by date   All posts3234
  2026237
  2025357
  2024357
  2023357
  2022351
  2021342
  2020349
  2019340
  2018332
  2017212

Forum & RTI 3,234 posts · page 225 of 270

Tuesday, 1 January 2019
RTI

Separate reply for separate RTI applications

Appellant submitted before the CIC that he has not received any reply from the CPIO or the FAA till date regarding his query about the ownership of a particular land. In response to a show cause notice for imposition of penalty, the PIO regretted that the RTI Application dated 31.03.2017 was not replied to. He further submitted that later, Appellant filed a RTI another RTI Application dated 02.02.2018 wherein he sought information which is covered in the information sought in RTI Application dated 31.03.2017 also. A reply dated 28.02.2018 was sent to the Appellant asking him to inspect documents and take copies as required. The PIO prayed that the show-cause proceedings may be dropped as there was no malafide intention in the failure to provide a reply on the RTI Application dated 31.03.2017 within the stipulated time frame. The CIC observed that the facts of the case reflect very poorly on the lack of rationality of the PIO even as malafide intention is not evinced. The CIC dropped the show-cause proceedings with a severe warning to the PIO to remain careful in future.
Comments
All the PIO’s should remember that each RTI Application has to be dealt as per the provisions of RTI Act. Merely on a belief that two very distinct RTI Applications seek similar information,a PIO cannot absolve himself from the statutory duty of replying to one of the RTI Applications within the stipulated time frame of RTI Act. Reply to one RTI Application cannot take care of the other even if the information is similar.
Citation: Kartik B Joshi v. CPIO O/o Cantonment Board, Devlali Cantt in Adjunct Decision File No. : CIC/IARMY/A/2017/155555/SD/Adjunct, Date : 26/12/2018
Dr. Anuradha Verma (dranuradhaverma@yahoo.co.in) is the co-author of the books: RIGHT TO INFORMATION – LAW AND PRACTICE and PIO’s guide to RTI. Her other articles can be read at the website of RTI Foundation of India at http://www.rtifoundationofindia.com/
Citation: Mr. Shiv Kirti Singh v. CPIO M/o. Finance in Complaint No. CIC/BS/C/2015/000189-BJ, Dept. of Revenue CBDT, Date of Decision: 17.04.2017, 29.11.2018
Forum

Problem can be easily solved

The Problem can be solved very easily if Brigadiers are placed in level 14, Maj Generals in Level !5 and Lt Gen in Level 16. There will be no need of any cadre restructuring or increase in posts. The present Level of 13A does not exist in civil hierarchy hence can be modified.
N Verma
Monday, 31 December 2018
Forum

Non-serious games have become political agenda of today

Sad that non-serious games have become the political agenda of today: perhaps a sign of the disengagement which will beget systemic collapse with all-round big losses for everybody, so-called winners included. Leadership failure and circumstantial acknowledgement thereof, appears to be the final writing on the wall for 2018. Let us hope that 2019 will show light on a path to happier times for India and humanity. Best wishes for the new year unfolding.
Namit Verma
Public Sector Enterprises are commercial organizations
Public Sector Enterprises are a commercial organization. If you people do not work and put the PSUs into red, then how can you expect the government to come out with proposal so early which favour the non performers from out of the scarce resources of the tax payers. I am not saying that you are a black sheep. Thing will take time. There is no bar on the PSUs who are on their own feet to give Rs.20 lakhs as gratuity to its employees.
Anurag Srivastava
Sunday, 30 December 2018
Forum

Functioning of NDA Government

The present government is suffering from a management crisis. There is no mechanism for checking the ground reality. There is no coordination between the government and its well-wishers. As a result, there is no tangible relief to the middle and the lower class. Even BJP Cadre is not able to get justice from different ministries because BJP does not know how to deal with the Babus and get the work done. As at the implementation level, there is no change, all good works done by the government have failed to generate the necessary support to the NDA.
Ajay Kumar Verma, ISS(Retd.)
Boosting credit growth
Government of India, as proposed by representatives of NBFCs sector to the Prime Minister on 26th December, 2018, is considering lending by Banks to NBFCs Sector as Priority Sector Lending. This move is to give boost to credit growth to MSME Sector, especially IFCI, a Government of India Company as also ND-SI-NBFCs registered with Reserve Bank of India.
BMA
Friday, 28 December 2018
Forum

Does PM wants to create unemployment for engineers from IITS/NITS ?

Does PM wants to create unemployment for class 1 engineer officers from IITS/NITS recruited through Indian Engineering Services (I.E.S.) exam. Bogibeel and other bridges are product of engineering marvels. Digital India has also been developed by IES techno-administrators. Should the country be run by non-technical IAS only. Then bridges and planes should also be made by IAS. Hope PM will protect engineer I.E.S. officers of all class 1 organised engineering services.
I.E.S. officer
Forum

UPA’ tenure bureaucrats frustrated

UPA’ tenure babu lobby is frustrated in NDA regime as they are unable to loot and they are sabotaging by giving internal inputs to UPA bosses. Classic example are implementation of enhancement of Rs 20 lakhs gratuity for retired CPSE employees w.e.f. March 29, 2018 instead of January 1, 2016 as recommended by cabinet committee in the month of September 2017, second, not implementing EPS 95 pension to all exempted CPSE's though SC and other High court issued orders. That is why many senior citizens ( around 80 lakhs) are annoyed with BJP govt, particularly against Modi & Arun Jaitely. This is ground level fact.
Rao
She is hard working, efficient and capable
I have known Seema since many decades when we worked in NTPC and subsequently as a project member of ADB. I think she is hard working, efficient and capable. Go for it my friend. Your well wisher.
Ajay Guha
Wednesday, 26 December 2018
Forum

Rusticate such officials

I certainly agree with the views. Certainly Modiji will be PM after 2019 elections and all the babus who are doing chamchagiri and are acting as info leaders to the previous govt and trying to spoil the image of the govt should be rusticated forthwith.
SriNivas
Bureaucratic sabotage responsible for delay
Yes, insider bureaucratic resistance and sabotage, for pro-congress culture officers, is responsible for large number of welfare schemes, not getting momentum, on ground.
Raj Kumar Pandey
Tuesday, 25 December 2018
Forum

No uniformity in timings of CGHS dispensaries in Delhi

There should be uniformity in timings of CGHS dispensaries to avoid any confusion - some close at 1.30 pm and most others at 2.00 pm. Registration timing in most of dispensaries is till 1.45 pm while in a few others, it is at 1.15 pm, but in actual practice, registration closes at 1.00 pm, like that at Kingsway Camp Dispensary, where computers are shut down exactly at 1.30 pm even when many registered patients, including senior citizens, wait for their turn. There should be a system that all registered patients are seen by the doctors. – Paul
They have had full 4 years plus and failed in putting out any stuff worthwhile. And they have 4 months to go! Good luck to this Government and yourselves. If removal is a solution to fight dissent, half the nation would be empty.
Srinivasan
Monday, 24 December 2018
Forum

Doctors at CGHS prescribe medicines even without diagnoses

Some CGHS doctors don't even see the face of the patients and start typing/prescribing the medicine, mostly Paracetamol and Avil.
Lakshmi
CGHS working efficiently and systematica lly in Bangalore
May be in respect of Delhi it may be correct. After retirement I live in Bangalore and the CGHS is working efficiently and more systematic. Doctors are helpful and sincere.
V Jayaraman
Forum

Kamal Nath is aware of situation !

Kamal Nath is an experienced campaigner and is aware of presence of Jyotiraditya Scindia in the state political scenario. He does not have an absolute mandate also.
Saumya
UPA’ tenure civil service officers frustrated
It seems that a band of civil service officers, who were in key positions during UPA rule, participated or aided/abetted in the loot, and feel frustrated that they are no more having the patronage they thought was their birthright, have been giving vent to their frustration by writing letters to the government, once in awhile, and publicising it. The idea is that if congress comes back to power , they will again get back their entitlements. The retired ones of course don’t matter, but there are still a large number of them who are occupying important positions, and sabotaging the efforts of government. NDA should find out and throw them out ruthlessly, else there may be more trouble
S Chatterjee
Friday, 21 December 2018
Forum

"This is the wake up call for you, Prime Minister, Sir "

The root cause of PM Modi's recent electoral reverses was his total inability to be a good listener of people's grievances and a genuine implementer of the same.
Endless rhetorics through monthly monologues like Man-ki-baat, was a flop show due to lack of people's participation.
Terribly stereotyped speeches with heavy dose of statistics, that no one is bothered about. The ground realities are totally at variance with boring statistics.
Being Out- of - sync with the ground realities resulted in arrogance of power, over-confidence and " I- am- the- custodian-of- all -wisdom - syndrome ". Consultative mechanism wiped out.
All signs of totalitarianism.
Regrettably, PM Modi’s failure in reining in his loose-cannons, goons and chaatukaars, led to his political waterloo ?
Public is angry, frustrated, disillusioned, disenchanted and in retaliatory mood.
A K Saxena ( A former civil servant)
Wednesday, 19 December 2018
Forum

Modi should come out of web of IAS cadre

Modi needs to come out of the web of the IAS cadre people and interact with the other cadre officials in order to understand the actual ground level situation and initiate remedial measure. He needs to ensure that central Ministries/Departments are on e-Office platform on e-Office by Jan 31, 2019. All websites are GIGW compliant by March 31, 2019. All Ministries/Departments should update their manuals clearly defining the financial and administrative powers of officials positively by March 31, 2019. Revise and update the Central Secretariat Manual by Jan 31, 2019. Automatically the Governance will improve and the citizens will start reaping benefits from government in a speedy manner. The Department of Administrative Reforms is sleeping since long over these matters. Cabinet Secretariat needs to jump and hold the drivers seat on all the aforesaid facts.
BBS
BJP lost due to its arrogance
It is due to Arrogant attitude/behaviour of BJP/RSS leaders coupled with Goondaism let out by party workers due to which they lost the Elections. They need to reign in their workers otherwise people will forget some of the good work done by the Government.
S Gopal