Debate: Corruption — 23 Aug 2017
DEBATE (1) Corruption
There is no doubt that the rampant corruption in all walks of our lives today in our country is the biggest threat not only to our democratic set up but to the very survival of this country in its present form. Without going in to the details of cause and effect of this menace, let me come to the crux of the problem.
1) Let us recall the way of lives of our leaders like Dr. Rajendra Prasad, and many of the cabinet colleagues of Pandit Nehru where living with modesty was a norm rather than an exception. Today the PM has to remind his cabinet colleagues again and again not to avail 5 star hotel facilities and shun other perks of PSUs with very little impact on them.It only shows that we have very little or no commitment to our society in general where the per capita income is $ 1850 per annum.
2) The same extravaganza applies to babus, media persons, judiciary and even business persons. The shocking part is that if somebody talks of simplicity in day to day life,he is looked at scornfully.
3) Whether Modi would succeed in eliminating corruption in India or not would depend on two things namely:
a) He has to select ministers and CMs who are very modest in their living standards and fire others who do not heed to his advice of living with such modesty.
b) He has to confiscate all the properties of at least 50 most corrupt politicians( including 5-6 BJP one's also) and at least 100 most corrupt IAS/IPS/IRS officials in the country and put them behind the bars so that people in general are forced to stop treading this path of living beyond means any more.
I am hopeful that once he is re-elected in 2018/2019, he will try to do it with all his might and chances of his success are very high.
Santosh Roongta retired CMD of a central PSU .
Compliments to P.M.
The advisory issued by the Prim Minister to the Union Ministers not to stay in five star hotels while on tour, and that instead of that thy should stay in Govt. accommodation like Circuit Houses and V I P Guest Houses needs to be appreciated by all right minded citizens. It is another step in curbing misuse of authority and show off tendency of the high ups. Another good piece of advise is not to avail of transport and other facilities from the Public Undertakings under their Ministry. It is common knowledge that nt only the Miinisters, even the family members and the personal staff of the Ministers ask for luxury cars, air tickets and providing refreshments and snacks for parties at their offices, residences from the PSU. The Govt. already provides each Mnister cars as per entitlement and entertainment expenses as per scale prescribed, then why there should be need not call for cars and other facilities from PSUs. All VIPs should exercise self restraint and set personal example of right conduct. Another bold initiative that we are waiting from the P M is to close down the heavily subsidised canteen of th Parliament , for the Ministers and M.Ps. are already getting a fat remuneration and a big packet of other allowances. In addition giving them subsidised food and tea etc. is not justified. If the P M is asking the well to do tx payers to give up their gas subsidy and othr subsidies, why can't the Parliamentarians give up this subsidy and set an example. I would also recommend that the Ministers and M.Ps. should travel economy class and not in business class or first class while going by air. They are peoples' representatives and should sit with the people and not with the elite business community which travels in higher classes. The other perks like telephone allowances and free tickets for spouse and others should also be curtailed.
S C Agrawal
D G Police Retd.
It’s time for Cabinet Secretary to take call
Now that Prime Minister has given directions to his Cabinet Ministers to not to misuse perks & facilities especially vehicle of PSUs, it is time for the Cabinet Secretary to issue similar directives to the Secretaries of all central Ministries & Departments. If he does not do so, then it means he gives his clearance to his fellow bureaucrats to misuse perks & facilities illegally. He should rember the mulching REC in the Ministry of Power.
B B Srivastava
Promotions of non-IAS services delayed !
Promotions of all non-IAS services are delayed. And this is done on purpose. The IAS feel insecure of any challenge to their hegemony. They are not satiated with the post of secretaries in all ministries, regulatory bodies and tribunals...they make sure that debureaucratisation decreases the size of all services-only their tribe is allowed to grow. Wonder why this tribe cannot even introduce their name without the suffix IAS-is it a written rule which compels them to mention it when they write a formal /informal letter, outside their residence... The constitution of India denounces discrimination-this usage of suffixes of one's cast (IAS) is the single biggest evidence of our colonial mindsets...
Vikram
There is no doubt that the rampant corruption in all walks of our lives today in our country is the biggest threat not only to our democratic set up but to the very survival of this country in its present form. Without going in to the details of cause and effect of this menace, let me come to the crux of the problem.
1) Let us recall the way of lives of our leaders like Dr. Rajendra Prasad, and many of the cabinet colleagues of Pandit Nehru where living with modesty was a norm rather than an exception. Today the PM has to remind his cabinet colleagues again and again not to avail 5 star hotel facilities and shun other perks of PSUs with very little impact on them.It only shows that we have very little or no commitment to our society in general where the per capita income is $ 1850 per annum.
2) The same extravaganza applies to babus, media persons, judiciary and even business persons. The shocking part is that if somebody talks of simplicity in day to day life,he is looked at scornfully.
3) Whether Modi would succeed in eliminating corruption in India or not would depend on two things namely:
a) He has to select ministers and CMs who are very modest in their living standards and fire others who do not heed to his advice of living with such modesty.
b) He has to confiscate all the properties of at least 50 most corrupt politicians( including 5-6 BJP one's also) and at least 100 most corrupt IAS/IPS/IRS officials in the country and put them behind the bars so that people in general are forced to stop treading this path of living beyond means any more.
I am hopeful that once he is re-elected in 2018/2019, he will try to do it with all his might and chances of his success are very high.
Santosh Roongta retired CMD of a central PSU .
Compliments to P.M.
The advisory issued by the Prim Minister to the Union Ministers not to stay in five star hotels while on tour, and that instead of that thy should stay in Govt. accommodation like Circuit Houses and V I P Guest Houses needs to be appreciated by all right minded citizens. It is another step in curbing misuse of authority and show off tendency of the high ups. Another good piece of advise is not to avail of transport and other facilities from the Public Undertakings under their Ministry. It is common knowledge that nt only the Miinisters, even the family members and the personal staff of the Ministers ask for luxury cars, air tickets and providing refreshments and snacks for parties at their offices, residences from the PSU. The Govt. already provides each Mnister cars as per entitlement and entertainment expenses as per scale prescribed, then why there should be need not call for cars and other facilities from PSUs. All VIPs should exercise self restraint and set personal example of right conduct. Another bold initiative that we are waiting from the P M is to close down the heavily subsidised canteen of th Parliament , for the Ministers and M.Ps. are already getting a fat remuneration and a big packet of other allowances. In addition giving them subsidised food and tea etc. is not justified. If the P M is asking the well to do tx payers to give up their gas subsidy and othr subsidies, why can't the Parliamentarians give up this subsidy and set an example. I would also recommend that the Ministers and M.Ps. should travel economy class and not in business class or first class while going by air. They are peoples' representatives and should sit with the people and not with the elite business community which travels in higher classes. The other perks like telephone allowances and free tickets for spouse and others should also be curtailed.
S C Agrawal
D G Police Retd.
It’s time for Cabinet Secretary to take call
Now that Prime Minister has given directions to his Cabinet Ministers to not to misuse perks & facilities especially vehicle of PSUs, it is time for the Cabinet Secretary to issue similar directives to the Secretaries of all central Ministries & Departments. If he does not do so, then it means he gives his clearance to his fellow bureaucrats to misuse perks & facilities illegally. He should rember the mulching REC in the Ministry of Power.
B B Srivastava
Promotions of non-IAS services delayed !
Promotions of all non-IAS services are delayed. And this is done on purpose. The IAS feel insecure of any challenge to their hegemony. They are not satiated with the post of secretaries in all ministries, regulatory bodies and tribunals...they make sure that debureaucratisation decreases the size of all services-only their tribe is allowed to grow. Wonder why this tribe cannot even introduce their name without the suffix IAS-is it a written rule which compels them to mention it when they write a formal /informal letter, outside their residence... The constitution of India denounces discrimination-this usage of suffixes of one's cast (IAS) is the single biggest evidence of our colonial mindsets...
Vikram