Monday, November 16, 2026
Live
“
“
Voices from the corridors

Whispers Forum

Debates, reader views and sharp takes on the issues shaping governance — a new conversation every week, archived by date.

0 posts 0 months Latest: 20 Feb 2024
  Browse by date   All posts3234
  2026237
  2025357
  2024357
  2023357
  2022351
  2021342
  2020349
  2019340
  2018332
  2017212

Forum & RTI 3,234 posts · page 76 of 270

Tuesday, 20 February 2024
Forum

Sponsors of farmers agitation 2024

People are angry at the irresponsible conduct of the agitators in the name of farmers. It is a ruse only. Green revolution has hurt the interests of countries like Canada, USA and others who have lost a huge market like India to sell their grain and other agri-products (recall PL-480 and its weaponization). India has started exporting instead- a double whammy. Holocaust is known to Indians but hardly “holodomor”, which is deadlier than holocaust as it is mass killing/genocide by starvation. For India the problems are many (akin to more thieves than police, more patients than doctors, more litigants than judges, more “for corruption parties” than those “against corruption”). We are told about the Bengal famine and blame the British for it (but it is not called holodomor). Why? Everyone of us must ponder this issue in the context of the farmers agitation 2024. It is part of a triple attack: K2 plan, food insecurity through Kisan Andolan and economic disruption by way of Hindenburg/Soros style abuse of the due process of laws. The sponsors want only Pappus for Modis. The farmers are going to be starved first by such agitation by creating artificial food shortage and liquidating the Soviet dictator J Stalin way later.
M L Gupta
Monday, 19 February 2024
RTI

How are the colleges accredited?

The appellant sought for certain information from University Grants Commission (UGC) - a photocopy of the rules that education institutions cannot keep original documents of students such as marksheet, passing certificate, Migration certificate and other documents. He further asked for the number of members of NAAC team visit a college during inspection, the checks carried out by them, cost for NAAC inspection per college / per university, source of UGC revenue etc. Dissatisfied with the response received, the Appellant approached the CIC. The CIC observed that the appellant communicated to the Registry that he had received the requisite information and was not willing to pursue the second appeal any further. The CIC held that there is no scope for further intervention in the matter.
Comments
The UGC website contains some information on their website such as Annual reports. However, most of the information sought in the RTI application ought to have been provided suo-motu by the UGC. In this case, the CIC should have directed the UGC to put the information on their website. It would be prudent for the UGC to consider putting up a series of FAQ’s for the benefit of the students and their parents.
Citation: Abhishek Ranjan v. University Grants Commission, Second Appeal No. CIC/UGCOM/A/2023/622787; Date of Decision: 16.01.2024
Dr Anuradha Verma (dranuradhaverma@yahoo.co.in) is a RTI Consultant currently working with IIM Visakhapatnam. She has co-authored the books, RTI Right to Information - Law and Practice and PIO’s Guide to RTI. She offers consultancy on RTI matters and Third party audit. Her other articles can be read at the website of RTI Foundation of India at the link www.rtifoundationofindia.com
Forum

Senior citizens not allowed visiting DDA’s sports complex

Setting up sports complexes in Delhi is laudable. I am a 70-year-old man and I gave up the membership of DDA’s Sports Complex in GTB Enclave in East Delhi. During extreme winter or extreme summer, senior citizens are advised not to visit the complex, similarly during rainy season, it is not possible for them to visit the complex. Thus, for most of the time, they are asked not to visit the complex.
Pradeep
Saturday, 17 February 2024
Forum

Setting up sports complexes in Delhi laudable

It is laudable that DDA has set up many Sports Complexes in Delhi and is reported to be adding on to them and improving upon the facilities therein. But no recreation facilities are being thought of for very senior citizens, like those over 70-75 years old and for the physically disabled. What about some facilities in these complexes for, say, bridge and carom?
Surinder Pal
Friday, 16 February 2024
Forum

Sonia Gandhi's shift to Rajya Sabha

Sonia Gandhi has filed her nomination papers from Rajasthan for the upcoming Rajya Sabha elections. Sonia Gandhi has been representing Rae Bareli in the Lok Sabha since 2004. This move has come at a time when Rahul Gandhi is on Bharat Jodo Nyaya Yatra and the timing of this Yatra is being criticized, opinion polls are predicting PM Modi's victory in the Lok Sabha elections for the third consecutive time. Congress leaders are leaving the party one after the other and questions are being raised about the coordination on seats between the parties of the opposition India Alliance. It is true Sonia Gandhi's decision marks the end of an era and perhaps the decision is a loss for the Congress and the opposition. Sonia Gandhi's presence in the Lok Sabha was encouraging not only for the Congress but also for the opposition. Her presence in the Lok Sabha provided encouragement and a voice for the opposition. This decision will take her away from direct electoral politics at a time when Congress is on the decline.
Nancy Singh Ahirwar
Thursday, 15 February 2024
Forum

Dos and Don’ts for RWA

It is high time that the Government of India lays down clear Dos and Don’ts for RWAs throughout the country,which the office bearers of RWAs should follow. Failure to do so, action should be taken by the Police and heavy monetary fines imposed on them.
S Gopal
Wednesday, 14 February 2024
Forum

Bad timing for Congress Party

Your whisper in the corridors gives accurate predictions on Congress party downfall. For Congress mukt Bharat guarantee of PM Modi its must for Congress to show doors to mass leaders and retain drawing room politicians with UN (urban Naxal) mind and background and reward them with Rajya Sabha tickets. The statements from Congress stalwarts these days in and outside parliament except a few exceptions like Manish Tiwari, Digvijay Singh are more of pure leftist thoughts of jealousy and targeting corporates creating wealth and jobs for the nation than true Congress ideology. The country needs a good opposition too when it has a powerful, popular global leader in PM Modi for a few more years but the Congress from Congress (I) is increasingly being seen as Congress (V) ie Venu which ultimately is not.
S Saboo
Tuesday, 13 February 2024
Forum

Highly demoralising and demeaning

This is highly demoralising and demeaning for a cadre which is so crucial for both centre and state but ironically, disowned by both.
Dr Anil Agrawal
Monday, 12 February 2024
RTI

Withdrawal of money using forged signature

The complainant sought details of action taken on a complaint of withdrawal of money from bank account using forged signature and using ATM. Dissatisfied with the response received from the PIO, the Complainant filed a First Appeal alleging that the information provided was incomplete, false and misleading. The FAA did not pass any order. The Commission observed that the respondent furnished point-wise reply, however, both the parties remained absent during the hearing, despite hearing notices having been served upon them. The CIC took a serious note of the absence of the PIO during the hearing without prior intimation and directed to submit written explanations citing reasons for their absence during the hearing before the Commission within 15 days from the date of receipt of the order. In view of the absence of both the parties and the matter not being pressed for, the Commission found no scope for further intervention in the matter and dismissed the dismissed.
Comments
A PIO should not abstain from hearing without prior intimation lest a show cuase notice is served for imposing penalty under section 20.
Citation: Heera Shauharat v. Punjab National Bank, Complaint No. CIC/PNBNK/C/2022/141431; Date of Decision: 01.02.2024
Dr Anuradha Verma (dranuradhaverma@yahoo.co.in) is a RTI Consultant currently working with IIM Visakhapatnam. She has co-authored the books, RTI Right to Information - Law and Practice and PIO’s Guide to RTI. She offers consultancy on RTI matters and Third party audit. Her other articles can be read at the website of RTI Foundation of India at the link www.rtifoundationofindia.com
Forum

"Appointment of CEC and ECs"

Apropos WIC Forum dated Feb 10.The idea of identifying the constitutional functionaries like the CEC and ECs through a committee representing all national political parties, is absurd. This would lead to their further politicization, impacting independence and transparency, the sine qua non for conducting free and fair elections mandated by the Constitution. Removal of CJI from the selection-cum-search committee by changing the procedure through legislative route (brute majority) is a regressive step, making the appointments in Election Commission arbitrary and discretionary, based on pick-and-choose. Sadly, the CJI ,as the custodian of the constitution, remained a mute spectator. He has gone down in public esteem due to his inaction. Stake-holders consultation was necessary. Going a step further, the public would uphold the idea of making appointments in all constitutional bodies like the EC,C&AG, and the UPSC by the same committee headed by the PM with LOP and CJI as members. Status quo ante must be restored. The Judiciary, as one of the pillars of Parliamentary democracy, must be respected. This would further enhance the image of PM Modi in the public eye.
A K Saxena (A former civil servant)
Friday, 9 February 2024
Forum

Country has no more T N Seshan

The PM should never be allowed to select the CEC. The country has no more TN Seshans. The candidate who ends up being selected will merely end up being a "Yes sir yes sir three bags full". It should consist of leaders from all parties.
Ashok Menon
Thursday, 8 February 2024
Forum

"Poor public services delivery"

There has been a continuous decline in the quality of public services delivery mechanism in the country. Thanks to deteriorating quality of civil servants, recruited by the Union and States public services commissions. The selection process is flawed, reduced to a university type examination. The aspirants from the science and technical streams get unintended advantage over those from the humanities streams. No level playing field. The perception that the candidates from the former streams are better is misplaced. Consider the following facts.
The present selection methodology is elimination-based rather than merit-based. The scheme of examinations must be re-visited both by the UPSC and the States PSCs to eliminate mediocrity in the quality of civil servants.
More importantly, the marginalised sections of society especially those from the rural areas must be given opportunities including access to free coaching facilities. At present, the benefits of reservations in services are cornered by the more fortunately circumstanced urban youths. Those in the rural areas continue to stoically suffer untouchability.
Another point. Granting endless number of attempts and increased eligibility age limits available to various categories, defeat the purpose of selections. These criteria must be reviewed so that civil servants from all categories get equal opportunity to reach the top echelons of bureaucracy.
Under the present dispensations followed by the Union and States public services commissions, the quality of selected candidates become the casualty. No initiative, no service-oriented mindsets. This leads to poor public services delivery mechanism. The weightage of marks earmarked for interviews must be increased
Concentration of decision making authority in the PMO and CMOs, must be minimal. At present, the administrative ministries especially in the States, have been robbed of initiatives in decision making. The authority lies in the hands of select coteries of pliable bureaucrats, carefully chosen by the respective chief ministers. The coteries behave like powerful bureaucrats-turned-politicians. The public services delivery act remains unimplemented with no penalties imposed on the defaulters.
A K Saxena ( A former civil servant)